Site Meter Tiny Treasury » Blog Archive » War of Words Wednesday: Censorship

War of Words Wednesday: Censorship

by Kelly

So here’s a twist on the War of Words Wednesday. Since we’ve been talking about censorship this week, I am interested to see which, of any, of these banned books you think should be removed from school libraries. This is a list of books subjected to banning in the US and UK which I compiled using information from the library at the University of Pennsylvania, The File Room Project and the American Library Association. The list includes books which have been deemed inappropriate for minors or students over time.

Hamlet, Macbeth, King Lear, Twelfth Night (use of adult language, sex, violence) - Shakespeare
Little Red Riding Hood (alcohol reference) - Brothers Grimm
Tom Sawyer, Huckleberry Finn (racial slur) - Mark Twain
Forever (sexuality) - Judy Blume
Of Mice and Men (inappropriate language) - John Steinbeck
I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings (sexuality, adult language) - Maya Angelou
Harry Potter series (magic, witchcraft) - J.K. Rowling
The Great Gatsby (sexuality) - F. Scott Fitzgerald
Catcher in the Rye (adult language) - J.D. Salinger
The Color Purple (sexuality, violence, racism) - Alice Walker
Gossip Girl series (sexuality, drug use, adult language) - Cecily von Ziegesar
Charlotte’s Web (death, potentially offensive to Muslims) - E.B. White

Do you agree with any of these books being banned? If you don’t believe that banning is appropriate, should there be an age restriction on any of them?

Are any books missing from the list?

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


3 Responses to “War of Words Wednesday: Censorship”

  1. Kari Says:

    Wow I have read almost all the books on this list. Many of them when I was young. Huckleberry Finn was one of my favorite books when I was little. I loved Catcher in the Rye in high school. I just can’t believe that some many classics are up for being banned many of these have been read for years and years. Many of the same books were required reading in school. I am pretty sure I am came out as a normal person who loves to read much to some of these stories. My children and I are in the process of reading Tom Sawyer this summer. I am reading it to them if I think anything in it is questionable I stop and explain about when it was written what the world was like then how the world is different now and how if we aren’t aware of what was done wrong in the past we can’t know not to make the same mistakes in the future. It is just like when a child makes a mistake they learn from it and know that it won’t be tolerated again. My children so far are great children, great students, respectful to others, and have a great thrist for reading and knowledge so even if these books get banned I will continue what I am doing because I will always be aware of what they are reading. Why ban books if you think a book may offend you then don’t read it.

  2. April Says:

    I have read all of those except the Gossip Girl series and Forever. My mother spent her 35-year teaching career reading Macbeth and Hamlet to high school students. The only one I might pause at would be The Color Purple for teens younger than high school. It does have some disturbing imagery of abuse and mistreatment. The reason I say that, though, is that I work for a child psychologist who treats child and teen victims of abuse. Maybe I am just more sensitive to it. However, I think once a child reaches high school level they need to begin learning about and coping with the very real reality represented in the book.

  3. The Book Stacks » Blog Archive » A Bit of a Round Up and A Gorilla Librarian Says:

    [...] over at Tiny Treasury has been debating censorship this week. Why not stop by and weigh in on this controversial [...]

Leave a Reply


About Tiny Treasury

It's impossible to get rid of a bad children's book once it has entered your house. In fact, if history teaches us anything, it's that it will become a favorite. Your child will cling to it, sleep with it and worst yet, require you to read it over and over again.

At tinytreasury.com, our mission is separate the good from the bad. If I can save one parent from having to read a rhyming book about dancing pigs, then I'll know I've done my job.

Tiny Treasury Author(s)
    » Jackie

Blogging Flair

2007 Banned Books Week: Ahoy! Treasure Your Freedom to Read and Get Hooked on a Banned Book StumbleUpon View blog authority Literature Blogs - Blog Top Sites

Books & Writing Channel Posts

Hot Off The Press

  • Recession 10 Steps to action plus Bake cookies
    Yep the world economic forecast is swirling in a big pit. Drastic survival measures may be in order. Fortunately my Mom and Grandmothers lived through the great depression. My paternal [...]
  • The Office Season 5 Episode 2 Business Ethics
    This episode was amazingly funny from start to finish!!! I can't get over it. I know when the show has delivered a really good episode because the half-hour program seems all too short. Let's [...]
  • TNA Mick Foley on IGN Ep.4, Bella Twins FCW - Video
    IGNSports has got an video interview with TNA's Greatest Acquistions, Mick Foley. Here Foley gives you indepth views of his current TNA status. which TNA superstars he would like to get into the ring [...]
  • Poem, 10 October 2008
    She sat on the tree and kept looking down on me As if we had been gone a long time Whoa Baby, it's me I said and gave her a wink Hi Baby, it's me she said and that made me blink She never called [...]
  • TNA's Christian Cage:Being Next TNA Champ and More
    Slam Wrestling has got an article on TNA's superstar, Christian Cage. Here are few highlights to the interview: His Thoughts on becoming the new TNA world champ: "My goal? To get to the top," [...]
  • Fall foods
    I know that we're well into October and the weather has been on the chilly side. But I've still been in denial about it being fall. This CSA share is proof that it's summer no more. Two heads [...]
  • Pushing Daisies Circus Circus Ratings
    Is it time to start the Save Pushing Daisies campaign? Should fans and begin sending pies to ABC? The show once again suffered in the ratings this week, losing some 700,000 viewers more. 8.00 [...]
  • Interview with Douglas Carlton Abrams, Author of The Lost Diary of Don Juan
    Hello and welcome to Fiction Scribe, Mr. Abrams. Let’s start with getting to know you a little better. List five things you feel define you as a person. 1. Love – for my wife, friends, [...]
  • Dodgers Lose to Phillies, 3-2; Red Sox and Rays; Playoff Reflections...
    Last night, the Dodgers and Phillies played game one of the NLCS and everything came down to a fateful sixth inning. Los Angeles went up 2-0 in the top of the first inning, thanks to Manny Ramirez -- [...]
  • An Easy Fix for Foot Pain
    If foot pain is throwing a wrench in your daily plans, there’s a simple solution that could get you back to high-stepping. Research shows that orthotics -- custom-made insoles that help realign [...]